How Much Are Car Loans
An analysis by the independent online auto-loan marketplace Outside Financial has found that dealers are charging an average markup of $1,791 per loan. By contrast, in 2003, Vanderbilt University economist Mark Cohen estimated that 10 percent of loans to Nissan’s borrowers were marked up by more than $1,600.
Anyone who considers purchasing a vehicle with dealer financing should worry about the fact that the government allows these concealed price hikes. But people of color are particularly vulnerable, given that they are historically discriminated against by the auto industry.
A series of studies I authored and co-authored in the 1990s found that auto dealers consistently charge black consumers prices that are hundreds or thousands of dollars more than their offers to white shoppers.
As dealers earn more and more profit from finance fees, the discriminatory practices appear to be at work there, too. In the past few years, Honda and Toyota have both settled lawsuits brought by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau for more than $20 million because minority borrowers were charged higher interest markups than equally qualified white borrowers. Neither company admitted wrongdoing.
The CFPB and other government agencies should be on the lookout for ways to better curtail dealership lending abuses. Yet instead of stepping up enforcement and protecting customers, the CFPB has rolled back rules on discriminatory lending practices and decreased enforcement of existing protections. Just last year, the Senate used the Congressional Review Act to overturn a CFPB rule that explicitly banned auto lenders from charging discriminatory fees on the basis of race.
California is one of only a handful of states to have experimented with capping the amount by which dealerships can mark up their loans. For loans with the standard repayment term of five years, a California dealership can mark up the interest rate by only 2.5 percentage points.
To help assure that markups are reasonable, auto dealers should be required to engage the free market. If an auto-finance contract would earn the dealership profits over, say, $1,000, the dealership should be obliged to offer the consumer the option of having the loan auctioned on an open-access lending site such as Lending Tree. That way, bidders in the open market, and not sales agents in a back room, can determine the fair interest rate.
At a minimum, borrowers should be told how much their loan is being marked up, how much the dealer stands to profit and how that compares with average markup profit at that dealership.
. If customers were actually informed about the markup fees in their contracts, they could then decide whether to shop around for a different loan.
Capping interest markups and better harnessing market competition can protect consumers while still ensuring that dealers can earn a reasonable return for connecting customers to financing.